I’ve tried a few clothing subscription services, including Wantable, but decided to try Stitch Fix. It started in 2011 by Katrina Lake and offers styles for women, men, and children. I wanted to see how it compared.
Signing up was easy, but the style quiz was more detailed than I expected. I had to provide my sizes, clothing categories, favorite colors, patterns, features I wanted to highlight, denim preferences, style personality, and budget. I could also use Pinterest boards or app likes to help the stylist.
I chose to receive boxes every month, but you can also get them every 2-3 weeks or quarterly. Each box, called a “fix,” includes five items. There is a $20 styling fee per box (or £10 in some areas), which goes toward any items you keep.
My First Impression
When my first box arrived, it was wrapped in recycled paper. Inside, I found a letter from my stylist, cards for each outfit, and an invoice showing the total cost with and without the 25% discount for keeping everything. There were also instructions for checking out and using the app.
The five items included tops, trousers, a cardigan, dresses and tees. The brands were Madewell, Free People, Calvin Klein, Farm Rio, and Whistles.
Trying everything at home was easy. Some pieces fit well, while others do not. The fabrics were different; jackets and jeans often lasted for years, but shoes or synthetic tops wore out quicker.
Some of their items, like tees, feel overpriced to me. I liked the stylist notes that gave outfit ideas. I could provide feedback, request the same stylist for consistency, or switch stylists if I wanted.
Interaction With Real Stylist and StyleFile
Stitch Fix has both human stylists and technology (StyleFile) to match clothing style. While the technology helps suggest items, interacting with real people was a major advantage for me.
StyleFile is another thing that I liked. StyleFile can track my personality, my unique style, and I can also add notes about my preferred neckline, fabric type, and occasions. This service is really helpful to change your wardrobe with the new styles that you will love.
Benefits and Drawback of Using Stitch Fix
We all know not anything is 100% perfect, everything has their pros and well as drawbacks, and same way the StitchFix also have. The below is the pros and cons what I have noticed using Stitch Fix:
Pros
- Shipping and returns are free with prepaid envelopes.
- You can try items for 3 days, with an option to extend it to 30 days. This saves time and lets you try clothes at home with your own mirror and accessories. It’s perfect for busy people, travelers, and those facing life changes or limited shopping options.
- Prices range from $25 to $500, averaging about $60. If you keep everything, you get a 25% discount, and the $20 styling fee goes toward your purchases. This can be cheaper than hiring a personal stylist, which costs $25 to $120 per hour.
- Stylist notes and curated boxes help me find new styles and brands more easily.
Cons
- Fit inconsistencies are common—some fabrics, like polyester tops, fray or split quickly.
- I have got two repeated brands and listened to them even repeat the color and styles.
- The Style Pass is not free; it costs $49 per year.
- Some boxes are perfect, while others disappoint me.
- Some items are overpriced, like you can find the same product for cheaper on other platforms like Poshmark.
Wantable vs Stitch Fix- Which is Best?
As mentioned earlier, I have tried both Wantable and Stitch Fix, and each has its benefits. However, Wantable is better at customizing each box to my style.
One main benefit of Wantable is its try-on period. You get five days to decide, while Stitch Fix usually gives you 3 to 4 days.
Wantable also makes it easy to talk to your stylist. You can chat directly and refine your next box, which feels more personal. Stitch Fix has feedback options and StyleFile features, which I liked, but I prefer the personal touch with Wantable.
If I had to choose one, I would go with Wantable. Its flexibility, longer try-on period, and attentive stylist support give it an advantage. Stitch Fix is fun for discovering new brands and trends, but Wantable suits my style better.
|| Read More: Wantable vs Stitch Fix – Best Cloth Styling Service
Overall Experience
Stitch Fix is better to give a try to styles outside your comfort zone, like skinny or barrel jeans, mesh ballet flats, or trendy tops. Stitch Fix is popular mainly because of social media and its referral credits.
This service works well for people who have limited time, need to update their entire wardrobe, or want to maintain a consistent style.
Overall, Stitch Fix is convenient and saves time. It also introduces new brands and outfit combinations. However, it can be frustrating sometimes due to repeated styles and designs, but it’s still great for refreshing your wardrobe.
